Heat leading to rental shortage indicates a situation where increased temperatures cause a scarcity of affordable housing, potentially due to higher energy costs or property damages.
In the scorching summer months, maintaining a comfortable living environment can be a challenge for tenants and landlords alike. Monika Schmid-Balzert, deputy managing director of the Munich Tenants' Association, has emphasized that heat alone may not always justify a rent reduction. However, there are circumstances where a rent reduction could be valid.
According to the Los Angeles County ordinance effective from January 1, 2027, the acceptable room temperature in summer rental apartments to avoid justifying a rent reduction is a maximum indoor temperature of 82 degrees Fahrenheit in all habitable rooms. For small property landlords, this 82-degree maximum is initially required in at least one habitable room, with full compliance for all habitable rooms by January 1, 2032.
When it comes to courts' decisions on heat-related rental defects and rent reduction claims, several factors are taken into account. These include whether the landlord has maintained the indoor temperature within acceptable standards or local regulations, the seriousness and duration of the excessive heat condition, the availability and functioning of cooling devices, the condition and age of the building structure and equipment, compliance with local housing codes, and whether the tenant notified the landlord of the heat issue and whether the landlord took timely corrective action.
In some cases, exceeding limit values for room temperature in new buildings may justify a rent reduction. Tenants can reclaim the possibly overpaid portion of the rent due to the defect retroactively. However, in old buildings or those with large window areas, tenants may expect higher temperatures in the summer. A rough guideline for room temperature is between 26 to 28 degrees Celsius.
To strengthen a case for a rent reduction, tenants are advised to document and measure temperatures daily and to notify the landlord of the defect in writing, along with the information that the rent is being paid provisionally. Documenting and providing evidence can help prevent the risk of termination due to payment default from the landlord.
Courts judge cases of excessive heat in rentals individually, considering local ordinances like the 82-degree maximum standard, the landlord’s efforts to comply, and the overall habitability of the rental unit. If room temperatures during the day get much warmer than this guideline, there may be a rental defect that could justify a rent reduction.
In conclusion, tenants should be aware of the acceptable room temperature in their rental properties and should document any instances of excessive heat. By notifying the landlord and providing evidence, tenants can potentially claim a rent reduction if the indoor temperature exceeds the acceptable limit. It is essential to maintain open communication with the landlord and to act promptly when issues arise to ensure a fair resolution.
[1]: [Link to source 1] [3]: [Link to source 3] [5]: [Link to source 5]
- In some regions, such as Los Angeles County, the acceptable room temperature in summer rentals is capped at 82 degrees Fahrenheit to prevent justifying a rent reduction.
- For tenants living in old buildings or those with large window areas, a rough guideline for room temperature during summer is between 26 to 28 degrees Celsius.
- Exceeding limit values for room temperature in new buildings, or maintaining temperatures beyond the 82-degree maximum standard in some localities, may justify a rent reduction claim.
