Choosing Between Marble and Quartz Countertops: What's Best for You?
Revamping a kitchen can be a daunting task, filled with numerous decisions. From choosing the right cabinets to selecting flooring, even picking out hardware can feel like a significant decision. However, perhaps the most crucial choice is selecting a countertop material, and two popular options are marble and quartz. While they might appear similar at first glance, there are several key differences between the two.
To shed some light on the debate between marble and quartz countertops, we spoke with interior designers Shannon Askinasi from Ash and Pine Interiors and James Pearse Connelly, founder of JPConnelly.com.
Quartz: The Durable Choice
If durability and maintenance ease are your priorities, quartz is the obvious choice. Shannon Askinasi explains, "Marble requires a lot more maintenance than quartz because it's porous and can easily stain and etch. The marks left behind on marble can be difficult to remove without the help of a professional." James Pearse Connelly echoes her sentiment, "Marble isn't the most durable material. It's a bit more brittle, so don't drop the magnum of wine! And marble has pores just like skin, so it looks beautiful, but it can absorb ink, dye, even markers unless you take care of it."
Quartz's non-porous nature makes it resistant to stains, scratches, and heat. It doesn't require sealing and can be cleaned with soap and water, making it an incredibly low-maintenance option. However, quartz does have a minor drawback when it comes to heat resistance. Askinasi explains, "One downside to quartz is that it is not heat-resistant. While marble is heat-resistant up to 350 degrees Fahrenheit, quartz is not." To avoid damage, simply invest in a trivet or two, or make sure your hot pots and pans cool off before setting them down.
Marble: The Aesthetic Queen
If natural beauty and aesthetics are your primary concern, marble cannot be beat. As James Pearse Connelly puts it, "Marble offers a luxurious, unique and elegant look with natural veining that gives the eye a focal point and movement in the space." Shannon Askinasi shares the sentiment, "I've yet to find a quartz that's as beautiful as marble, even though technology continues to evolve to make the veining in quartz look more natural." While quartz can mimic the appearance of marble, it will never fully replicate the colors, lines, textures, and variations that are inherent in real stone.
That being said, the beauty of marble comes with its own set of challenges. It is more susceptible to damage due to its porous surface, making regular sealing and careful maintenance a requirement. However, the patina that develops over time can add character to the countertops, creating a unique, one-of-a-kind look.
Cost Considerations
Just like any home renovation project, cost is a significant factor to consider when selecting a kitchen countertop material. Quartz is generally less expensive, but the price can vary significantly depending on the design and patterns you choose. Shannon Askinasi warns, "If you're going with a digitally printed quartz, be mindful of additional labor charges. With printed quartz, the veining only appears on the surface, so all of your countertop edges need to be mitered. At the end of the day, there might not be a cost savings if you select a pricier quartz over marble."
Marble, on the other hand, is a more premium option, with prices ranging from $50 to $150 per square foot, depending on the type and quality. High-end marble like Calacatta marble can cost even more. While marble's luxury and prestige can increase the resale value of a home, it also requires more maintenance and investment.
Ultimately, the choice between marble and quartz countertops depends on your budget, lifestyle, and design preferences. If you value durability, low maintenance, and a consistent appearance, quartz is the right choice for you. If you're captivated by marble's natural beauty and are willing to invest in regular maintenance, marble is the way to go. Regardless of your choice, both materials can make your kitchen a stunning, functional space for years to come.
When contemplating kitchen decorating, the selection of countertop material is a critical decision. RealSimple's article highlights the debate between marble and quartz, two popular options. During our conversation with Shannon Askinasi from Ash and Pine Interiors and James Pearse Connelly, it became clear that the choice between these two materials hinges on various factors.
If you're prioritizing durability and minimal maintenance, quartz is the recommended choice. Its non-porous nature makes it resistant to stains, scratches, and heat. Australia's Aussiedlerbote magazine also acknowledges the benefits of quartz, emphasizing its low-maintenance qualities.
On the other hand, if natural beauty and aesthetics are your primary concern, marble holds its own. Its luxurious appearance, unique veining, and potential to develop a characterful patina provide a distinct charm not easily replicated by quartz. Ultimately, both marble and quartz offer appealing qualities and can significantly contribute to the appeal of your home decor.
